Should You Make a Claim? Key Considerations for Home and Auto Insurance

When unexpected damage occurs to your home or vehicle, filing an insurance claim may seem like the obvious next step. However, deciding whether to file a claim isn’t always straightforward. It can have lasting effects on your insurance premiums and coverage. There are three critical factors to consider before filing a claim.

1. Understand Your Deductible

Your deductible is the out-of-pocket amount you must pay before your insurance coverage kicks in. The amount varies depending on your policy and type of coverage, so reviewing your deductible for both home and auto insurance is essential.

For example, if your deductible is $1,000 and the repair costs are $1,200, filing a claim may only result in a small payout from your insurer. In such cases, it might be more cost-effective to handle the repair yourself.

Tip: Set up an emergency fund to cover smaller repair costs, so you can reserve your claims for significant, unavoidable expenses.

2. Be Mindful of Your Claims History

Every claim you file becomes part of your insurance history. Multiple claims, especially within a short period, can lead to higher premiums. Some insurers may even impose restrictions or limits on policies with frequent claims.

Before filing for minor damages, ask yourself if it’s worth potentially increasing your long-term insurance costs. Maintaining a clean claims record gives you an advantage when shopping for new policies or negotiating terms with your current insurer.

Pro Tip: Avoid unnecessary claims to retain flexibility in the insurance market and secure competitive rates and coverage.

3. Get an Estimate Before Filing

Before deciding whether to file a claim, always get a repair estimate. Whether it’s a cracked windshield or a small roof leak, knowing the repair cost can help you determine if filing a claim is necessary. If the cost is close to or below your deductible, it may be better to avoid involving your insurer altogether.

Pro Tip: Use this opportunity to shop around for affordable repair options. Costs can vary between contractors or repair shops, so a little research can save you money. Understanding the repair scope also helps you plan financially, whether you file a claim or not.

How Nightlight Insurance Agency Supports You

At Nightlight Insurance Agency, we’re here to make navigating these decisions easier. By reaching out to your agent before filing a claim, you can save time, money, and stress. We’ve helped many clients avoid unnecessary claims and identify alternative solutions that protect their financial well-being. If filing a claim is necessary, we’re equipped to advocate for you and streamline the process.

Here’s how we can help:

  • Review Your Coverage: We’ll ensure you understand what’s covered under your policy and clarify any exclusions.
  • Guide You Through Next Steps: Whether it’s filing a claim or exploring other solutions, we’ll help you choose the best path forward.
  • Set Expectations: We’ll prepare you for what to expect in terms of timelines, costs, and required documentation, reducing uncertainty and stress.

Final Thoughts

Insurance is there to protect you from major financial hardship, but not every situation warrants filing a claim. By assessing your deductible, maintaining a clean claims record, and obtaining repair estimates, you can make well-informed decisions about when to involve your insurer.

At Nightlight Insurance Agency, we’re committed to being your trusted partner in these decisions. Have questions or need advice about your policies? Contact us today. Our team is dedicated to helping you balance protection and affordability, ensuring your financial future is secure.

brett
Brett Dyer, Founder & President, Nightlight Insurance Agency

Call or Text Today (512) 488-3586

Curious if you have the right insurance coverage at the best price? Get a FREE, no-obligation quote from Nightlight Insurance today. We proactively shop & compare your polices with a wide range of insurance providers, finding you the best combination of cost, and coverage.

insurance carriers